Morales v. Unilever United States

Case # 13-cv-02213
Case Name Morales v. Unilever United States
Jurisdiction US District Court for E.D. CA

Defendant retails hair products under the "TRESemme Naturals" brand.  Plaintiffs allege that consumers were mistakenly lead to believe that the products contained no synthetic ingredients by the prominent "natural" labeling on the products.  As a result of this labeling, consumers paid a premium for the product, expecting it to contain exclusively natural ingredients.

Final Approval Date 10/18/2016
  1. Final Approval granted.
  2. The Helfand Fee objection was overruled.
  3. Objector Helfand appealed the Final Approval.
  4. Objector-Appellant Helfand received an extension of time to file his opening brief.  On the day the brief was due, he filed a motion to voluntarily dismiss his appeal.
Dismissal of Last Appeal 03/10/2017
Attachments Docket Report.pdf
Corrected Second Amended Class Action Complaint.pdf
Preliminary Approval Order.pdf
Plaintiff's Motion for Final Approval.pdf
Final Approval Order.pdf
Added to Index
Last Updated

Objection of Steven F. Helfand

Objectors Steven F. Helfand
Signers Steven F. Helfand
  1. Release is overbroad, since it includes personal injury claims.
  2. Class counsel's fee application relies on an inflated lodestar.

Objector Helfand partially withdrew his objection, upon learning that the release did not, in fact, include personal injury claims.  He continues to object to the Fees Motion.

In his appellate mediation statement, Objector Helfand noted that he is "open to a variety of case resolution concepts." (see Helfand Mediation Statement, page 2)

Attachments Objection of Steven F. Helfand.pdf
Defendant's Response to Helfand Objection.pdf
Plaintiff's Motion for Final Approval.pdf
Partial Withdrawal of Helfand Objection.pdf
Appeal of Objector Helfand.pdf
Helfand Mediation Statement.pdf
Dismissal of Helfand Appeal.pdf
Helfand Appeal Docket.pdf
Added to Index
Last Updated